The Birchbark House

I wanted to like this book, by Louise Erdrich, I really did. Back in May, when I wrote my post on Caddie Woodlawn and was chastised because I wasn’t sensitive enough to the depiction of Native Americans in that book, this one was suggested as an alternative. And I really wanted to like it.

On one level I did. It’s full of passages and descriptions of Native American life in the mid-1800s. The things they did to survive. The relationships they had with each other. The interactions with white people. Omakayas, the main character, works and plays and makes friends with bears and crows and is annoyed by her little brother, Pinch.

But, the problem was: there was no story. Or, rather, there was a story there (a baby girl — Omakayas — is the only one on her island to survive the small pox, is rescued, and eventually helps her adopted family through another bout of the disease) but it wasn’t told well at all. In fact, it was incredibly difficult for me to get through this book because it was, well, boring. They work, they sleep, they argue, they get sick, they survive to get maple sugar in the spring. I didn’t care for any of the characters, not even when baby Neewo dies (it was so surreal that I didn’t feel any emotion at all for anyone). Pinch was supposed to be annoying, but I found him to be downright mean. Even Omakayas, who I felt was supposed to be spunky, fell flat.

At least I can say I tried, right?

Filler and Tips

I’m still not done with the book I started… it’s one of those really slow ones, even if it’s a YA book. So, more filler (lots of filler this week.) Becky tagged me for the blog tips meme (ish thing). And I thought, hey, it’s a meme, and I’ve been tagged (ooh, me, me!), so why not? (Took me a while to come up with something. All the good advice is already taken!)

START HERE:

It’s very simple. When this is passed on to you, copy the whole thing, skim the list and put a * star beside those that you like. (Check out especially the * starred ones.)

Add the next number (1. 2. 3. 4. 5., etc.) and write your own blogging tip for other bloggers. Try to make your tip general.

After that, tag 10 other people. Link love some friends!

Just think- if 10 people start this, the 10 people pass it onto another 10 people, you have 100 links already!

1. Look, read, and learn. **-http://www.neonscent.com/

2. Be, EXCELLENT to each other. ***-http://www.bushmackel.com/

3. Don’t let money change ya! *-http://www.therandomforest.info/

4. Always reply to your comments. ********-http://chattiekat.com/

5. Link liberally — it keeps you and your friends afloat in the Sea of Technorati. **** http://chipsquips.com/

6. Don’t give up – persistence is fertile. **-http://www.velcro-city.co.uk/

7. Give link credit where credit is due. *******-http://www.sfsignal.com/

8. Pictures say a thousand words and can usually add to any post.*** –http://scifichick.com/

9. Visit all the bloggers that leave comments for you – it’s nice to know who is reading! * –http://stephaniesbooks.blogspot.com/ ***

10. Make a blogger template unique: change the background colour, or add a background picture to your header. http://chris-book-a-rama.blogspot.com/

11. Ensure font size of words is not too small and colour of words don’t drown in background. – http://booksloveme.blogspot.com/

12.Do at least a few of the blogging quizzes available. It lets people know a little more about you.** http://3m3am.wordpress.com

13. Even when you disagree with a blogger’s post, don’t leave rude comments. Always be kind. ** http://apatchworkofbooks.blogspot.com

14. Join the blogosphere community. Participate in carnivals. Join challenges. Have fun.* http://blbooks.blogspot.com

15. Remember, though, that’s it’s just a blog. Relax and enjoy the ride. http://melissasbookreviews.blogspot.com/

–End Copy —

I’m supposed to tag five people. But many of my usual-tag list has been tagged already. So, if you feel like doing this one, and you haven’t, you have my permission to go for it.

Guest Blogging Princess Power

I got this book from Andi as a review book for Estella. When the book got here, I looked at it and though, “Huh. Not what I was expecting.” The back of the book said for ages 9 to 12, but M (our resident 9 to 12 year old) looked at it and said, “It’s a bit young.” So, we passed it on to C (our resident 6 to 8 year old). I told her that if she read it, I’d let her review it for Estella.

Turns out, though, that it really is youngish for the readership over at Estella. But, I did promise C that she could do her review. So, without further adieu, here it is:

Title and author of book:
Princess Power: The Stubbornly Secretive Servant, by Suzanne Williams. It’s Book #5 in a series.

Fiction or non-fiction? Genre? Fiction.

What led you to pick up this book? It looked cool. Like you were going to solve mysteries, have adventures.

Summarize the book: The plot was Jonathan, who was supposed visit Princess Gabrielle and Prince Jerome, went missing. The four princess friends decided to figure out what happened to Jonathan.

What did you like most about the book? I liked that the princesses were always ready for new things to pop up. I liked that most of the time, one of the princesses (Tansy) played her magic flute so they could hear each other’s thoughts.

What did you like least? That the plot was all about Jonathan, a prince that was coming to the royal ball. (He’s also a magician.) I also didn’t like that Thomas, Jonathan’s servant, did all the dumb stuff. It got boring after a while.

What did you think of the main character? There were many main characters. Gabrielle and Jerome (her husband) didn’t do a lot of cool stuff, but Gabrielle had a baby in the last chapter. The other princesses were all different. Fatima rocked; she was adventurous, and had a magic carpet. Lysandra was Gabrielle’s sister, so got to be an aunt. She was also the one that figured out the mystery (Tansy helped). I thought Tansy’s magic flute rocked. Elena was pretty boring though.

Any other particularly interesting characters? No.

Do you recommend this book? Yes, for girls who like princesses and adventures.

My note: I think this book is in an odd category. It was a bit difficult for C to read, the names especially being difficult to pronounce. (She would call Fatima, “fat-ma” and Jerome “jer-um”) But, unless M is unusual for her age (which I concede that she may be), I can’t see a 10-year-old liking an underdeveloped and simplistic princesses adventure/mystery book. It really is a glorified beginning-reader chapter book.

All in a Word

I’m in-between books right now. It’s usually so hard for me to move on after Harry (I figured this one out last time, when I had a run of books I hated. I realized it was just that I was still thinking about Harry). Thankfully, this time, I had a book review to do for Estella, so I moved right along. But, since I don’t typically post my Estella reviews ahead of time, I thought I’d use this as filler until I finish the book I started last night. I saw this one over at Bookfoolery and Babble. She said anyone could steal it, so I did. 🙂 Deal is, you have to answer the questions with only one word.

1. Where is your mobile phone? Bag

2. Relationship? Long-term

3. Your hair? Dishwater

4. Work? Kids

5. Your sister(s)? Friend

6. Your favorite thing? Books

7. Your dream last night? Forgotten

8. Your favorite drink? Rootbeer

9. Your dream car? Hybrid

10. The room you’re in? Basement

11. Your shoes? Flipflops

12. Your fears? Telephone

13. What do you want to be in 10 years? Content

14. Who did you hang out with this weekend? Potter

15. What are you not good at? Cakes

16. Muffin? Blueberry

17. Wish list item? Sleep

18. Where you grew up? Michigan

19. The last thing you did? Laundry

20. What are you wearing? T-shirt

21. What are you not wearing? Watch

22. Your pet? None

23. Your computer? Oldish

24. Your life? Busy

25. Your mood? Depends

26. Missing? Memory

27. What are you thinking about? This

28. Your car? Minivan

29. Your kitchen? Works

30. Your summer? Short

31. Your favorite color? Leaf

32. Last time you laughed?
Yesterday

33. Last time you cried?
Saturday

34. School?
BYU

35. Love?
Soulmate

Feel free to give it a whirl.

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

Wow. JK Rowling really knows how to write an ending.

I wrote that one-line review two years ago, after I read Half-Blood Prince, and I’ve been hoping that Rowling lived up to it. I’m happy to say that, in my opinion, she has. It’s not what I expected, though I have to admit that I was right on one account (but I’m not going to tell you what; not enough people have read it yet). No, it was better than I expected. It was not just a good ending for the Harry Potter books, but a good book: gripping, intense, soulful. It made me cry, several times. It kept me on the edge of my seat for most of the day. It was a mature story, dealing with mature themes, but not necessarily an adult one. It definitely isn’t a summer popcorn novel; it’s incredibly somber and sad. But with all that, I found it incredibly satisfying. Which is all I really wanted out of an ending.

What did you think? (Can we keep it spoiler free?) If you do want to join in a discussion that isn’t spoiler free… there’s a discussion being sponsored by Dewey at discussdeathlyhallows.

Waiting with Baited Breath

I was going to do a retrospective of my experiences with Harry Potter. Something along the lines of what Lisa at Bluestalking Reader did. You know: how I discovered it through a friend in 1999, went whole hog by that Christmas, but how we didn’t really get into the hype until the 5th book, which we picked up on the publication date (rather than waiting), but really really didn’t get into the whole lets-all-read-this-book-on-the-same-day thing until last time, when Hubby picked it up at midnight on the pub day, and we both devoured it in about 25 hours.

But then, I saw this in the morning paper, and thought it was much better than anything I could write.

I’m not going to the midnight release party; I enjoy my sleep too much. But Hubby and M are off at about 9:30 tonight. Hubby’s planning on diving right in once they get home, and hopefully finishing it soon enough on Saturday so that I can have my turn. And we reserved a copy at the library (we’re number 88, and they’re getting 100 copies, so we should get one tomorrow!) for M to read, since she was unhappy with being third in line.

See you sometime early next week with my thoughts on the book. Have a great Harry weekend!

All that Harry Potter Stuff

Overheard in Target the other night:

Teen #1: “Harry Potter is so, like, overdone!”
Teen #2: “Well, it is like so popular, with the books and movies and everyone reading them.”
Teen #1: “Yeah, but it’s on everything. Look: there’s Harry Potter pens and bags. I’m so sick of Harry Potter!”

And you know, in a way, Teen #1’s right. It’s one thing to sell a book or a movie, but the world is totally saturated with Harry Potter stuff. From low-end items like gift bags with Daniel/Emma/Rupert’s faces splashed on them, to the higher end stuff, like the Triwizard Champions wand set, which sits proudly in M’s room.

So, in honor of there being only two days left until the end, I set out to find the most unusual, most unique Harry Potter kitsch out there.

In my looking, I found lots of the usual stuff: t-shirts, posters, bags. This was my favorite:

Amazon had a whole four pages of Harry Potter watches. And if you aren’t a Gryffindor fan, there are shops for Ravenclaw, Sytherin, and Hufflepuff houses, too. They’re even pandering to the parents who want educational toys for their kids, but still want Harry Potter toys (there’s this one, too). It’s never too early to get Halloween costume ideas. You could try McGonagall, Flitwick, Hooch, or Dumbledore this year, instead of the usual Harry/Hermione fare.

Though, I have to admit, this is rather frightening:

The merchandise isn’t limited to the tons of costumes or Lego toys out there. Love Harry so much that you would like to have him around all the time? Try the Dumbledore’s Army throw pillow:

(Throw Pillows not your style? Try the Marauder’s Map wall scroll instead) Even better: have Daniel Radcliff right next to your head every night!

Under the category “completely impractical but probably collector’s items somewhere”

And, hands down, the thing that made me laugh the most (found on Ebay, of course):

Try that one on for size. I’m done being saturated.

Let’s Play Stump the Muggle

First, a story (geez, I’m sound more and more like my dad as I get older!): Last year, for our family reunion talent show, we convinced M to get up in front of the family and declare that she could answer any question asked her about the Harry Potter books #1-6 and movies #1-4. Amazingly, she did. From the easy ones (What class does Snape teach?) to the more difficult (What portrait hangs over Dumbledore’s desk?). I’m sure she’s not the most versed person out there, but she was pretty impressive.

She was also the inspiration for today’s post: Let’s talk trivia!

Test your own knowledge of Harry trivia with the Harry Potter Mega Quiz.

Or, take a stab at our library’s trivia questions:
1. What wood was Harry’s wand made out of?
2. Whose hair was Hermione supposed to get for her Polyjuice potion?
3. How many people was Sirius Black accused of killing and with what spell?
4. In the Tri-wizard tournament’s second challenge, what charm did Fleur use?
5. What are the name of the creatures that pull the carriages that Harry can see but Ron can’t?
6. According to Dumbledore, what is Voledmort’s sixth Horcrux?

If you think you’ve got a good question, you could try to stump M. Any question posed, she’ll answer (without looking it up, I’ll make sure… if she looks it up, I’ll let you know ;).

At the very least, it’s a fun diversion for a hot summer’s day.

As for M, she’s spending her day memorizing the Sorting Hat Song and “studying” for the trivia contest at the Grand Hallows Ball on Friday night.

Harry Potter Video Bonanza

Well, maybe not a bonanza, but I liked the way it sounded.

I confess that I’m borrowing this idea (and some of the videos) from Fuse #8. Giving credit where credit is due and all that. She has a mini-HP Video Sunday post here, and another video to watch here.

In the interview department, you can see one with JK Rowling (on the Jonathan Ross show on the BBC) here. It’s fun (and a little risque), and she keeps things pretty close. It interesting, though, that she lets slip that Deathly Hallows is a “bloodbath”. Hmmm….

I’m sure there’s more out there (isn’t there always?), but mostly I’m using this as an excuse to post our family’s favorite Potter video diversion: Potter Puppet Pals and the Mysterious Ticking Noise. (I dare you not to sing it after you watch!)

Harry Potter Linky Goodness

So, to celebrate today, I’m going to link to several HP posts I’ve found over the past few weeks. (Think of it as a HP carnival; if I missed something important, by all means, let me know!) Go, enjoy, leave a comment.

First, there’s hubby’s extremely popular Harry Potter predictions post. It’s what generates the most traffic for his site… wonder why? He says he’s going to put up another one this week, his second-to-last-HP-post-ever. If he gets around to it, I’ll link to it.

Erin, at Miss Erin, has been celebrating the release of Deathly Hallows for the past two weeks with a collection of Harry Potter quotes. My favorites have been the Luna days. It’s been fun to browse through.

You should definitely pop by Brooklyn Arden, and visit Cheryl, one of the few people in the world who have actually read Deathly Hallows (though she’s not telling!). Check out her post, in which she becomes incredibly(!) famous.

Ron Charles, book critic for the Washington Post, decries the HP series (and adults who read it) as cultural infantilism. Over at the The American Scene, they’ve posted a response. As has Kathryne, over at The Longstockings. Take a minute to read their other Harry posts, too. (found via A Chair, A Fireplace & A Teacozy, where Liz has her own post about HP bashing, too.) Oh, and Colleen at Chasing Ray also puts in her thoughtful two cents in defense of the books.

On the lighter side (I found this through the Bookworm Carnival — go visit that, too — at the hidden side of a leaf), Bob at bobarama dot com describes what he’s going to do to avoid being told the ending of Deathly Hallows before he reads it. (He’s also got a post about the movie, as well as other linky goodness…)

Alan Jacobs blogs for Books & Culture about his predictions and hopes for the seventh book.

I’m sure there’s more (I know there’s more, but I can’t remember where… ARGH!). Let me know, and I’ll post updates.

Update #1 (see… I knew there was more!) via Becky: Over at Say No to Crack, a very amusing comparison of Harry Potter and Star Wars.

Update #2: I said when Hubby got his HP post up, I’d link to it. He did, so here it is.

Enjoy!