by Emma Straub
First sentence: “The pool deck of the American Fantasy never smelled worse than it did first thing in the morning on turnaround days.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!
Review copy provided by the publisher.
Release date: April 7, 2026
Content: There is swearing, including multiple f-bombs, an almost on-screen sex scene, and talk of sex. It will be in the Fiction section of the bookstore.
This follows three people on the cruise ship American Fantasy during the BoyTalk (think NSYNC or Boys to Men) weekend. Sarah, who is the band handler, is coming off a bad breakup with her girlfriend, and trying to manage the huge egos of the band and the insanity of the fans without losing her mind. Annie, who is on the cruise after a bad divorce only because her sister is a huge fan, but her sister couldn’t come due to an injury. She’s navigating her first BoyTalk cruise on her own, dealing with the excesses as well as an abrupt change at work – her boss promoted the intern over her. And Keith, one of the BoyTalk band members, unhappy in his marriage, only showing up to do these sorts of things because his older brother, Shawn, demands it. He hates the weekend, he hates being in the band, he hates everything and is just trying to make it through the weekend.
This is a very internal book; everyone is dealing with something and everyone is trying their utmost to manage it without it getting messy. And it wasn’t bad. Straub is a good writer, and I always appreciate an older main character who is dealing with changes. And yet. I think genre fiction has warped my expectations because I was disappointed in the ending. I was disappointed that nothing was really resolved, that nothing really changed, that the story just stopped. It very much was a portrait of a middle, and I wanted something… more.
That said, I’m not sorry I read it.





















