by Diana Wynne Jones
First sentence: “Polly sighed and laid her book face down on her bed.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!
Content: There’s some intense situations and mild swearing. It’s in the YA section (grades 6-8) of the bookstore.
It took me a bit when reading this to remember that it was a re-read. But I hit a point – maybe about a third of the way in — where it felt familiar, and I looked it up. Sure enough: I had read it before.
Since I already did a thorough review, I’m just going to jot down my thoughts revisiting this book 11 years later. First: Polly’s parents are terrible. Absolutely terrible. So, no wonder she attaches herself to Tom. He’s a father figure, an older sibling, a friend who believes in and humors her rather than shutting her down all the time. And then, in the end, he becomes a romantic interest? Honestly? I found that creepy. He’s at least 15 years older than her, and he’s been with her since she was 10. Creepy.
That said, I did like Polly and Tom’s adventures, and Polly trying to figure out as a 19 year old why she had two sets of memories. I don’t think Jones does romance terribly well, but then, I don’t think this was supposed to be a “romance”. I really appreciated the essay at the end of the book where Jones explained where the idea for Fire and Hemlock came from, and what she was attempting to do. Namely: have a girl be the heroic protagonist of a book. We kind of take it for granted that girls can do that now, but back when Jones was writing (this came out in 1985; I don’t know how I missed it, it would have been perfect for me back then), there just wasn’t a lot with girls playing the hero.
What this did make me realize is that I’ve only ever read two Diana Wynne Jones books, and that is something I should probably fix.
One thought on “Fire and Hemlock”
I found this one creepy, too! And very puzzling – if it’s trying to retell Thomas the Rhymer or Tam Lin, I couldn’t follow. But there are so many other excellent Diana Wynne Jones books out there! I really enjoyed Deep Secret and the Merlin Conspiracy, which have the benefit of being a duology rather than the really long Chrestomanci series (which is still good, but long and full of lots of characters to be kept track of.)