Well-Seasoned Reader Challenge: We’re Off!

To travel the world, experience new places, meet new people, enjoy yummy food. You can link to all your reviews, recipes, thoughts, ruminations at the review blog here. If you are without a blog, and would like a space to put your thoughts, drop me an email, and I’ll make you a team member of the review blog.

I’m really looking forward to this challenge. Thanks so much to all those who have decided to join me on this trip. And if you haven’t signed up yet, it’s not too late to join in the fun!

Happy New Year!

Interesting People, Amazing Places, and Good Food

This is a sticky post; scroll down for newer posts…

I’ve been thinking about whether or not I want to do the Expanding Horizons Challenge again next year. And… I think not. Before you get all depressed (like you would. Really.), I’m not doing away with it entirely. I just came up with another idea for a challenge instead. It was born out of my love of food books, my missing Lesley’s Armchair Traveler Challenge this year (I don’t think she did it at all…), and my desire to host a challenge, but not the exact same one I did last year.

This year, I give you the Well-Seasoned Reader Challenge.

Here’s how it works:

Rule #1: The challenge runs from January 1 to March 31. (No cheating and starting before!)

Rule #2: You must read three books. After that, it’s up to you how much you want to read.

Rule #3: The books must:

have a food name in the title
OR
be about cooking/eating
OR
have a place name in the title
OR
be about one (or more) person’s travel experience
OR
be about a specific culture
OR
be by an author whose ethnicity is other than your own (see, I squeezed it in!)

I’ll leave it up to you to choose how the three books you read fit the criteria.

Rule #4: They must be middle-grade on up, but can be either fiction or non-fiction.

The purpose, this winter, is to take yourself someplace out of the ordinary, to go on a literary trip, whether that be challenging your expectations, discovering a new place, or enjoying the experience of reading about good food, places, and people.

Sign up using the Mr. Linky below. I’ll probably set up a blog for the challenge sometime before January. This post will stay up until the challenge starts.

http://www.blenza.com/linkies/autolink.php?owner=megcateali&postid=27Oct2008

December Jacket-Flap-a-Thon

Last one for the year. I’ve enjoyed thinking about jacket-flaps this year, and have learned that mostly it’s personal taste whether they “work” or not. In general, though: shorter is better, without giving away important (or near the end of the book details), while keeping to the style of the book all contribute (generally) to a good jacket flap.

I don’t think I’ll keep this up, though, next year (unless there are some of you that REALLY want me to…). Perhaps I’ll find some other way to keep track of my monthly reading.

5. Shooting the Moon (atheneum books for young readers):Jamie thinks her father can do anything… until the one time he can do nothing. When twelve-year-old Jamie Dexter’s brother joins the Army and is sent to Vietnam, Jamie is plum thrilled. She can’t wait to get letters from the front lines describing the excitement of real-life combat: the sound of helicopters, the smell of gunpowder, the exhilaration of being right in the thick of it. After all, they’ve both dreamed of following in the footsteps of their father, the Colonel. But TJ’s first letter isn’t a letter at all. It’s a roll of undeveloped film, the first of many. What Jamie sees when she develops TJ’s photographs reveals a whole new side of the war. Slowly the shine begins to fade off of Army life – and the Colonel. How can someone she’s worshiped her entire life be just as helpless to save her brother as she is? From the author of the Edgar Award-winning Dovey Coe comes a novel,both timely and timeless, about the sacrifices we make for what we believe and the people we love.”

Slightly misleading… it makes you think her plays a more active role than he actually does (he kind of is an overarching presence, rather than an active player). But it captures the tone of this coming-of-age book well.

4. Persuasion (Quality Paperback Book Club): “In a letter to her niece, Jane Austen described Anne Elliot — the shy, intelligent heroine of Persuasion — as ‘almost too good for me.’ An increasingly spinsterish heiress, Anne is slighted by her spendthrift father and attendance social circle because of her past engagement to Frederick Wentworth, a young naval officer considerably below her in social class and prestige. Persuasion begins seven years after the end of that engagement, when Wentworth is thrown back into Anne’s sphere and the two are left to resolve the smarting wounds of their past liaison. Powers have shifted: Wentworth’s distinction has risen estimably in rank and measure, while much of Anne’s youthful beauty is gone. Persuasion, which some critics speculate is based loosely on Austen’s memories of a mysterious suitor, is the author’s most serious, compelling novel, a deeply felt tale of retaliation — and forgiveness — in the face of abiding love.”

It’s not often that I’ve liked a QPBC blurb; usually they’re abominable. But I think they do Persuasion justice.

3. A Christmas Carol (Dover): “In October 1843, Charles Dickens — heavily in debt and obligated to his publisher — began work on a book to help supplement his family’s meager income. That volume, A Christmas Carol, has long since become one of the most beloved stories in the English language. As much a part of the holiday season as holly, mistletoe and evergreen wreaths, this perennial favorite continues to delight new readers and rekindle thoughts of charity and good will nearly 150 years after it was first published. With its characters exhibiting many qualities — as well as failures — often ascribed to Dickens himself, the imaginative and entertaining tale relates Ebenezer Scrooge’s eerie encounters with a series of spectral visitors. Journeying with them through Christmases past, present and future, he is ultimately transformed from an arrogant, obstinate and insensitive miser to a generous, warm-hearted and caring human being. Written by one of England’s greatest and most popular novelists, A Christmas Carol has come to epitomize the true meaning of Christmas.”

Writing a blurb for something as well known as A Christmas Carol has got to be difficult. This balances information between the history behind and the story of the book quite nicely.

2. Alvin Ho (Schwartz & Wade books): “Here are some things you should know about Alvin Ho : 1. He is afraid of everything. Trains, bridges, substitute teachers, girls, school. Everything. 2. He is from Concord, Massachusetts, which is hard to spell. 3. He loves Aquaman, Wonder Woman, and all the superheroes of the world. In fact, he is a superhero himself — Firecracker Man! 4. He is trying very hard to be a gentleman, like his dad, but there are a lot of rules and they are hard to remember. 5. He can talk at home and on the school bus, but never, ever at school. It’s just too scary. (See #1.) And there’s a lot more to learn about this amazing kid, so meet Alvin Ho…”

Cute, clever, sweet… keeps the style of the book wonderfully, and entices just enough without giving much away at all.

1. Yellow Star (Marshall Cavendish): “In 1939, the Germans invaded the town of Lodz, Poland, and moved the Jewish population into a small part of the city called a ghetto. As the war progressed, 270,000 people were forced to settle in the ghetto under impossible conditions. At the end of the war, there were about 800 survivors. Of those who survived, only twelve were children. This is the story of one of the twelve.”

Short, to the point, and powerful.

The One Worst:
Thank You, Lucky Stars (Schwartz & Wade Books): “It’s the first day of fifth grade, and Ally is totally psyched. She and Betsy, her best friend — okay, her only friend — are in the same class. They’re even going to sing “Bridge Over Troubled Water” together in the annual talent show. Ally is sure this is going to be the best year ever. But suddenly Betsy is ignoring her, and Ally doesn’t have a clue why. What’s worse, Betsy’s spending every minute with their sworn archenemy, Mona; they’re wearing matching jeans skirts, eating lunch at the same table as with the other cool kids, even planning to sing in a rock band together for the talent show! Now practically the only kid who wants to do stuff with Ally is the weird new girl, Tina, who wears her hair in Princess Leia buns and seems determined to make a fool of herself in the talent show. How could fifth grade, which looked so promising from a distance, turn out to be so lonely? Will disco, Ally’s favorite dance, make a comeback at the talent show? And can Ally be friends with a girl who enjoys being different… even if she knows Tina is a kindred spirit?”

I think it tries to capture the tone of the book, but just ends off coming annoying. I didn’t particularly want to read the book after reading the blurb, even though it turned out to be fairly cute.

Just Because….

I can’t hijack Hubby’s blog, like he did mine

(His bachelor’s graduation — he had two more over the years; we were engaged at the time.)

I need a filler for today…

(He’s the cutie on the far right.)


(He’s standing second from the back. The really amazing thing about this picture is that his older brother — the one in the back — is only a year older than he is. )

He does the philosophical ruminating, and I do the rest 😉 …

(He’s the second one from the left — I think it’s cute that he wore hats!)

I feel a need to embarrass him publicly 🙂 ….

But mostly because He’s turning FORTY today (!) and that’s something to celebrate, even over here.

(He’s the baby in this one.)

I bummed a few pictures off his brother, who had access to the ones at their parents’ house, because I thought it would be fun to take a little walk through (not quite) forty years of history. And because it’s always fun to see pictures of someone you only knew as an adult when they were kids.


Happy Birthday, Russell.

My Best of — Cybils Middle Grade Panel Edition

We’ve hashed, discussed, chatted, pleaded, and, in the end, came up with a shortlist, which we turned into our panel organizer today. The official lists are scheduled to go up on the first of January, so you’ll have to wait until then to find out what they are. As is to be expected, because of the nature of panels and compromises, not all of my favorites from the 72 books (of the 129 on the original list) I read made the shortlist. But, I think they deserve some recognition, if only because I loved them. 🙂

The ones that got 4.5 to 5 stars (5 stars on my Goodreads page, since they don’t do 1/2 stars)
The Penderwicks on Gardham Street, by Jeanne Birdsall
Shooting the Moon, by Frances O’Roark Dowell
The Girl Who Could Fly, by Victoria Forester
Diamond Willow, by Helen Frost
Moxy Maxwell Does Not Like Writing Thank You Notes, by Peggy Gifford
Every Soul a Star, by Wendy Mass
Forever Rose, Hilary McKay
Island of Mad Scientists, by Howard Whitehouse

And a few others worth mentioning:
Chancey of Maury River, Gigi Amateau
The Trouble with Rules, by Leslie Bulion
A Thousand Never Evers, by Shana Burg
The Walls of Cartagena, by Julia Durango
The Gollywhopper Games, by Jody Feldman
Savvy, by Ingrid Law
Bringing the Boy Home, by N.A. Nelson

Looking at the list, I can see that my old habits are still manifesting themselves: I like books by women authors, mostly about girls. I liked all three of the fantasy-middle grade crossover books. There are three historical fiction, but mostly it was realistic fiction that took the day (not counting the one horse book I found I liked).

I’ve thoroughly enjoyed working with the other members of my panel; they’re smart, passionate readers and we had a great pile of books to work though. Our two chats, and multiple Yahoo group discussions have been fascinating and enlightening and thought-provoking. It’s one thing to sit here and blather about how much I like a certain book; an entire other one to chat with six other people and have to come up with reasons in favor or against said book. It’s been a marvelous experience, one I’m very glad and grateful to have been a part of.

The Best of My 2008

I had so much fun doing this last year, that I had to repeat myself. 🙂

By the Numbers:
Middle Grade Fiction: 72 (being on the MG panel really shot the numbers through the roof!)
Young Adult Fiction: 53
Graphic Novels: 16
Non-Fiction: 14
Fiction: 42
Grand Total: 197

Challenges Completed: 9

And it wouldn’t be the same without the awards…

Best Adult Fiction: Dracula

Best YA book: The Patron Saint of Butterflies

Best Middle-grade book: Every Soul a Star

Best Fantasy:
A Curse Dark as Gold

Best Sci-Fi/Distopian: 1984 (even if it is depressing)

Best Graphic Novel (new this year!!) : Plain Janes/Janes in Love

Best Non-Fiction: John Adams

Best Romance: Crown Duel

Best (um, only?) Mystery (I still ought to read more…): The Winter Queen

Best Jacket Flap: The Fall of the Kings

Best Worst Jacket Flap: Matilda

And in other categories…

Books I should have read AGES ago: 84 Charing Cross Road, Call of the Wild, Right Ho, Jeeves, The Christmas Carol (well, I did read it before, but it’s been AGES)

Writing Style I Discovered I liked: Novels in verse, especially Diamond Willow and Song of the Sparrow

Favorite Challenge: Jane Austen

Best main character: Marvin from Masterpiece

Book for in-person book group I liked best: Suite Francaise

Book for on-line book group I liked best: The Glass Castle

Books I didn’t feel the love for: The Book Thief, Audrey, Wait!

Number of Shakespeare plays I read: 1 – Othello, but I saw two (Much Ado About Nothing and Pericles)

Number of books read that had something to do with Shakespeare: 4

Favorite use of Shakespeare’s plays: The Juliet Club

Books that Made me Laugh the most: The Year of Living Biblically, Leave it to Psmith, Island of Mad Scientists

Authors everyone else loves that I discovered I liked: John Green (but I think I like his vlog better than his books. Don’t shoot me.) and Maureen Johnson

Best Book from an author I previously didn’t care for: Airman

First-time authors I’d love to see more from: Susan Selfors (Saving Juliet), Daphne Grab (Alive and Well in Prague, New York), J. Scott Savage (Farworld: Water Keep)

Book I read the fastest: anything for the MG Cybils panel…

Favorite book from a series:
Forever Rose (with The Battle of the Labyrinth a close runner-up)

Best Arthurian book: Mary Stewart’s Merlin trilogy

Newbery Books I read: Good Masters, Sweet Ladies, Roll of Thunder, Hear my Cry

Books that made me want to go out and do something:The Omnivore’s Dilemma (change food buying habits), Every Soul a Star (look at stars and see a solar eclipse), Forever Rose (read the rest of the series), Dairy Queen (cheer!), Ten Cents a Dance (watch Swing Kids).

Books I abandoned: The Painted Drum, The Other Boleyn Girl, The Acts of King Arthur, Blue Bloods, Audrey Wait!, and a whole host of MG Cybils books.

Here’s to another great year!

Yellow Star

by Jennifer Roy
ages 9-12

This is not a happy book. Then again, what book about the Holocaust is a happy book? Granted, this one has a happy ending — it’s a story based on the life of the author’s aunt, and she survived — but getting there is harsh, depressing, and painful. Which means that Roy did an incredible job depicting the life and circumstances of her aunt Syvia’s childhood.

I’m trying to figure out a way to sum up the book without giving a mini-history lesson. For those who don’t know their World War II history, this story of one of the 800 survivors — only 12 of which were children — of the Lodz, Poland ghetto is not a fun one to read. Written in verse, I think to mimic the spare conditions of Syvia’s life, Roy captures the faith and family togetherness in the face of pure hopelessness quite well. There were parts that made me cringe — the Nazis deported all the children at one point, tearing them from their family; it was only through the courage and resorcefulness of Syvia’s father (and herself) that she managed to survive that time — and others that made me cry. I am amazed at Syvia, and at the luck — miracles? providence? chance? — that she had during her life. There were so many (more than 270,000 people lived in the ghetto at one time) that didn’t get her chance.

I’m not sure I can separate a critique of the book (can I say that in this instance I felt the verse was good, but unnecessary?) from the life. It’s a good book — not a great one — with a worthy story. And a story worth reading. Which makes the book worth reading, too.

A Very Public (And Enthusiastic) Thanks

I had the good fortune to have two secret Santas this year. First, my online book group did a gift exchange, and my Scret Santa sent me this:

Inside… was this:


I’m not sure if you click on the image whether or not you can read all those words, but it’s all the books I’ve read this year (up through the Christmas Carol). Which was totally and completely amazing. I wish she’d tell me who she is, though, because I’d love to use the pictures on the bookmark (which I suspect she took herself) as a new blogskin…

Then there was the Book Bloggers Christmas Swap, and I had the good fortune to have my name given to:

Michele went totally and completely above and beyond the call of duty:

The chocolates were perfect: delicious, and fancy enough so I didn’t have to share with the girls. 😉 And when I opened up the gifts this morning, I found:

THANK YOU! I’ve wanted both for a while, and I am totally happy to finally own them both.

We did get other booky gifts: my brother, bless him, gave us 5 Babymouse books, including the latest which we haven’t read yet. 🙂 And M got The Thief and its sequels, and C got The Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane. It’s been a very merry Christmas here. Hopefully, you all have had good booky holidays, too.

Happy Holidays!

May All Your Days Be Bookish and Bright

The two things we do well around here are books and blogs, so here’s our bookish bloggy Christmas letter!

K is our little spitfire, two and half years old, bouncing off the walls (when she’s not drawing on them), watching TV, going anywhere her older sisters go. Her favorite things are climbing (trees, couches, people), and kicking (balls, toys, people). And her favorite books are anything by Mo Willems, especially the Elephant and Piggie books. That, and Gingerbread Baby, by Jan Brett and Owl Babies, by Martin Waddell. You can’t say she’s not well-rounded.

A, who just turned five, is the most introverted child of the bunch. She doesn’t like starting anything, but once she gets there she’s just fine. The big start this year was preschool at West Heights Preschool. She loves her teachers, and has several friends at school. But her favorite time is when Mrs. Cindy comes, reads them stories, and lets them check out a book to take home. Out of all the books she’s brought home, Bats at the Beach, by Brian Lies has been everyone’s favorite. We were very sorry to send it back. She also has a fancy streak, and will never turn down the chance to bring a Fancy Nancy book home.

C, the budding writer and actress, is in third grade and still just as boisterous (which is a good word for loud and talkative) as ever. She has also discovered the joy of reading chapter books. Having the Percy Jackson series by Rick Riordan literally thrust into her hands by her older sister, she has found that she can’t stop reading them. Even though she enjoys reading books herself, she still loves to have Mom read out loud to her in the evenings, and still talks about when they read The Sisters Grimm series by Michael Buckley. Lots of fun voices to “do”.

Megan, who really epitomizes the word “bookish” around here, is 12, in seventh grade, and always has a book in her hand. In fact, when we asked what book we should use for her, she said “Give me a million years and maybe I could choose one.” This past summer, however, Mom introduced her to the pleasure of this:
which led her to read the original Jane Austen book. She liked it, enough so that for her history day project this year, she’s going to answer the question “What influence did Jane Austen have in history?” Something to ponder, anyway. Not one to be completely stuffy, she keeps up her fantasy reading, begging copies of Brisingr, by Christopher Paolini and Twilight, by Stephenie Meyer (heck, she read the whole series… and saw the movie) off her friends.

Hubby read a lot this year, but as usual the majority of it was scholarship for his lectures or news for his blog–he looks at his wife and daughters and how they plow through books (some of which are actual novels) and he feels terribly under-read. He keeps telling himself that he’s going get back to reading fiction someday, and perhaps one of these years he will. In the meantime, though, he feels blessed to have a good job at Friends University, and numerous colleagues and friends to learn from. His reading choice for the year was fascinating (but somewhat depressing) book, The World Without Us by Alan Weisman. (He figures he’s allowed a little melancholy; seeing as how he turned 40 this winter.) Two other books he thoroughly enjoyed were A Godly Hero, by Michael Kazin and Mountains Beyond Mountains, by Tracy Kidder.

And me, well, you know all about me. 🙂 Check back in a couple of days for my best of post…

May you all have a very Merry Christmas, and a blessed, bookish New Year!

The Foxes

Diamond of Drury Lane

by Julia Golding
ages 10+

You’re looking for a good adventure story right? Something light, a little bit thrilling, with a smidgen of romance and mystery and politics, and a lot of getting out of tight scrapes? You’ve come to the right place, my friends, and I offer you The Diamond of Drury Lane, the first in a series by Brit author Julia Golding.

Cat — short for Catherine — Royal is an orphan of uncertain (call her 12ish) age, and having been taken in at a young age by a Mr. Sheridan, owner of the Royal Theater (hence the last name) in London. She’s grown up backstage at the theater, and while her most estimable position is message runner, she loves her life. Then one day, she overhears Mr. Sheridan talking to a somewhat suspicious-looking man about hiding a diamond in the theater. The same day, a former slave named Pedro Hawkins (who plays the violin marvelously) shows up. Between these two events, Cat’s life will never be the same — or boring! — again.

The best word to describe the book is fun. It’s not deep, being meant for middle graders and all, but it keeps it’s pace well (especially since it’s 400+ pages long!), and keeps the reader, well me at least, engaged. There’s a lot of tight scrapes, a lot of close calls, a lot of adventure in the highest sense.

What really made the book for me, though, was Cat. I loved her. She had me wrapped around her finger, hook, line and sinker. Full of spunk and sass, but caring, loving and oh-so-needy, Cat’s voice completely carried the book for me. She was willing to trust others, yet smart enough to figure what she needed to out. The other characters — and there were a lot — weren’t quite as compelling, though I did like Johnny and Lord Francis. I couldn’t quite figure Pedro out, but I think that was intentional. He wasn’t supposed to be a cut-and-dried character, but I’m not sure Golding quite pulled the ambiguity off. Still, that’s a minor quibble in what is otherwise a clever book.

This is a good stand-alone book, which makes me wonder what Golding’s going to do with Cat in the next book. Here’s hoping it’s published in the US…

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.)