Sunday Salon: Books at the Bottom of My List

I’ve seen this floating around (I really should join in the Top Ten Picks at Random Ramblings; maybe when the girls go back to school…) and I knew I’d have something to add. (Of course I do.) The basic premise: what are the ten WORST books you’ve ever read?

Well, going through my lists and posts and memory (such that it is), I wasn’t able to come up with ten books that struck me as terrible, no-good, horrible, and you couldn’t pay me to read them again. But I did manage to come up with a few. Five to be exact. (There could be more books, but most are more “meh” than anything else, so I didn’t include them.)

Wuthering Heights, Emily Bronte: When I read this, all I could think was, “Good Heavens! It’s a complete train wreck.” I finished it; it’s very seldom that I actually finish what I think is a bad book, but I didn’t enjoy the experience. I didn’t like the characters, I found the plot creepy, and there’s no way you can pay me enough to read again. In short: It was a horrible, terrible, no-good, very bad book. And I don’t get the appeal of Heathcliff. Not at all. (Could someone please why they like him to me?)

The Sparrow, Mary Doria Russell: This one gets love from people, and out the outset it’s a very good science fiction book. There’s a lot about imposing on a new people; illusions to what the English and Spanish did with native populations, forcing their religion, introducing diseases. And I was enjoying it, for the most part. But then I got to the end! The end is SO important in a book, people, and I was sickened by the end of this one. Absolutely sickened. Killed the rest of the book for me, and I will avoid it like the plague.

Blue Bloods, Melissa de la Cruz
To be fair, I got about a third of the way through this book, and I bailed. So it’s not really one I finished. But, it’s more fluffy than I can handle: all who you know and what you’re wearing, and no plot or character or depth. M read the whole series — she was in the mood for “crap” — and said my fundamental problem is that I’m not a teenage girl. Well, then. That explains it.

Rules for Saying Goodbye, Katherine Taylor
It’s “deliciously witty” they told me. It’s “affecting”. It “winks at real life.” It’ll be fun. Yeah… like root canal is fun. It was painful. It was depressing. It was msierable people. The main character was unsympathetic. The plot was And — oh, yeah! — it was supposed to be satire. Yeah. I don’t get satire. Especially when it looks like this.

The DaVinci Code, Dan Brown
A caveat: I liked Angels and Demons. Really. Thought it was fun. Dumb, but fun. Granted, I read that one first, which, I think, makes all the difference. Not only was this one pretty much exactly like the first one, it was even dumber. I think Brown tried to go for some self-aware humor, but the whole “Indiana Jones in tweed” thing got old really, really fast. And it was so earnest: it’s all real, honest. (It’s just fiction, people. And lousy writing at that.) I always wondered how many people went to the Louvre afterward and whispered knowingly, “She’s down there!”

Bonus play: Hamlet, William Shakespeare: I don’t get it. In spite of my English professor friends’ attempt to convince me of the brilliance of this play — it seems to come up every single time we go see any Shakespeare play — I just. don’t. get. it. Hamlet annoys and irritates me. He’s wishy-washy, indecisive and a jerk. Poor Ophelia, getting mixed up with the self-absorbed bad boy. (Well, he’s not good.) Though I don’t quite understand why she’d want to off herself just because he doesn’t like her anymore. (Yeah, yeah, it’s been explained to me. I just don’t get it.) The play starts out boring and then eventually dissolves into incomprehensible. Thankfully, they all end up dead. (Sorry: spoiler alert.) That part, at least, makes sense.


So, what books are on your worst list?

7 thoughts on “Sunday Salon: Books at the Bottom of My List

  1. I'm 100% agreement on your thoughts on Wuthering Heights! I actually loved seeing people go through the readalong, watching how at first it wasn't a bad book, until slowly everyone wanted to scream bloody murder. šŸ˜€

    Like

  2. Confession: I kind of hate the Brontes in general, but Wuthering Heights is the WORST. I want to bash Heathcliff over the head with shovel. *cough* I mean, I thoroughly dislike the character of Heathcliff. šŸ˜‰

    But…but…Hamlet? I love Hamlet. ALTHOUGH, if I remember correctly, you also didn't like Catcher in the Rye, and for some reason I connect the characters of Holden & Hamlet. (Both kind of whiny, jerky crazy men who I find endearing, I guess.) Do you prefer Shakespeare's comedies?

    Like

  3. Oh, hooray, I'm not alone with Wuthering Heights! :-

    That an interesting connection, Cass, between Hamlet and Holden; I hadn't thought of that. I don't mind some of Shakespeare's tragedies (MacBeth, for instance, I find incredibly fascinating), but yeah, in general, I do prefer the comedies.

    Like

  4. I'm laughing about Blue Bloods! Not my favorite (I'm not a teenager either!), but they do improve after the first one. The brand-name dropping and descriptions of every outfit were getting a bit much

    Like

  5. i was of the same opinion on Wuthering Heights. i willed myself to read the first part (if only to see how Catherine bought it), and then decided to just bite it and read part 2. i have several friends who mark WH among their all-time faves and two who read it annually (in winter no less).
    i found an approach that worked for me, shifted a perspective differing from my friends', and now i have to say i like the book. i read it as bronte making fun of her contemporaries' romance lit and romanticism in general. (i rambled about it here, http://contemplatrix.wordpress.com/2010/01/08/contemplating-heights/) sometimes i do wonder if some of my friends have actually read the thing though.

    I would add Zadie Smith's On Beauty. I had to read it for a class, and while I can appreciate it intellectually (at some points) I didn't feel the slightest regret to giving it away after term..still surprised i could get through it.

    I like your list… I like that you are unafraid to list popular and classic works as a terrible experience.

    Like

Leave a reply to Cass Cancel reply