I first read this one, by Orson Scott Card, back in 1999, soon after it came out. I was leaving my job to spend some time in Germany so Hubby could do dissertation research, and my co-workers gave me a $100 gift card to Borders (they knew me so well!). This was one of the books I bought, and I was eagerly looking forward to reading it, being somewhat of a Card fan. This book was a big disappointment, though. I remember laying on the bed in our room in Germany, yelling at the book to stop moralizing and get BACK TO THE STORY. I sold the book as soon as we got back to the states.

And I have had no desire to read it since.

Until, now. And I did only because my on-line book group out-voted me (I voted for Ender’s Shadow, which I’ve also already read, but liked better…) and chose it to read for this month’s discussion. So, I checked it out from the library, tried to push away my pre-conceived notions of the book, and read it.

It’s not a bad story; in fact, it could have been a brilliant book. Put Sleeping Beauty in Russia, use Baba Yaga as the witch, and work magic into today’s world as well as that of long ago. Add some relationship complexity between the hero, Ivan, and the heroine, Katerina. He kisses her, but it’s not exactly love-that-works-at-first sight. They have to work to get their marriage to work, they have to learn to work together to save Taina from the clutches of Baba Yaga.

But, Card gets in the way of his own story. Or, at least, I got impatient with Card’s storytelling. I knew already that the book was full of tangents (though they weren’t as bad as I remember!), and yes, they still annoyed me. I decided, early on, to put a book dart whenever I got annoyed. There were at least a dozen. Now, in a nearly-400 page book, that’s not that many. Still, the story could have been tighter. If he had laid off the pages of descriptions (and barbs) of music, philosophy, religion, feminism, politics, culture, men-women relationships, and just plain musings, he could have had a tight, fun, interesting 250-page story.

And that book, I’d happily recommend to everyone. This one, not so much.

9 thoughts on “Enchantment

  1. Yeah, I had to read it for a Lit class my Senior year in college. FREAKED ME OUT. I hate horror stories, and reading the ending, alone, in my apartment, at night was not a good thing.


  2. I’m a huge Card fan. But I can respect the views of others 🙂 I enjoyed Enchantment. It’s not in my top five of Card novels, but apparently I’m not as annoyed as some of you are 🙂 As far as Card getting in the way of his own stories sometimes, I didn’t feel it so much with this one, but there have been a couple of Card books where I thought that was true.


  3. Melissa:I’ll get back to you on the first curiousity question. I’d have to have a list in front of me. And I might have to read summaries to refresh my memory. But the top five, that I can do. Ender’s Game is of course number one.And for the other four, the order would depend on the day and the mood.Worthing SagaPastwatchEnder’s ShadowSpeaker for the Dead


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s