by Brit Trogen and Kari Trogen
ages: 8+
First sentence: “If this were a proper world, beautiful faces would belong to beautiful people.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!

Margaret was not one of those Lucky People for whom Good Things happen. Rather, even though she was Good, bad luck seemed to follow her. First, her parents died, and no one wanted to take her in. Cousin Amos, finally did, but he never spoke, so Margaret lived in a House of Silence. Then he died, and Margaret was taken in by Great-Aunt Linda, who was Very Proper. Then, she died, and at ten years old, Margaret was left Alone.

She was given into the care of the Concerned Ladies Club, which delivered her to what seemed to be a Fairly Nice Orphanage, run by the Beautiful Miss Switch. Except — as we are often reminded in this slim book — Appearances Can Be Deceiving: Switch is much like her name. When adults are around, she is all kindness and caring concern. But as soon as they depart, her True Nature comes out: she is horrible. Worse than horrible: cruel.

Margaret suffers Innumerable Torments at the hands of Switch and her Pets (the good-looking orphans; the rest are Dregs), but to her surprise, she hears Voices. It turns out that the moths in the backyard tree can talk (and only Margaret can hear them), and they are more than willing to help her Get Rid of Switch Once and For All.

I know all the capital letters makes me sound a wee bit sarcastic, but honestly, I found this book to be sweet. It was just the right length for an 8-year-old to get a handle on, and the story was neither Too Scary, Too Dark, or Too Preachy. In fact, I found it to be Quite Sweet.

And sometimes, that’s Just Right.

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.) 

by Diane Stanley
ages: 10+
First sentence: “
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!

Molly, who was once a scullery maid and is now a lady, is best friends with the king. There’s no one he trusts more than her, it’s Molly (and her… something… boyfriend? best friend?… Tristan, as well as a knight, translator and a lady companion) that he sends to find the Loving Cup, something which the king will use to make a princess fall in love with him and marry him. (I think she was betrothed to his brother, who was murdered.)

Before I go much further, yes this is a sequel. And no, I didn’t read the first one first. (Though I kind of want to now. When there’s time.) In many ways, though, this one works as a stand-alone: Stanley gives you enough information to get the gist of the previous story, but I don’t think it got in the way of the telling of this one. I may have felt differently had I read book #1 first, but I didn’t, so there it is.

Anyway.

Molly goes on her quest to find the cup, which turns out her grandfather was a specialist in making. Also, it turns out her grandfather was from a super-secret magical place where Everything Is Perfect. Except when they find it, they arrest all Molly’s friends and take her prisoner. So they can teach her. And it’s for the protection of the city because if their secrets got out, it would be Bad.

For the most part, I really enjoyed this book. Molly’s a great character: strong, stubborn, opinionated, yet loyal, trusting, and resourceful. I enjoyed watching her figure out how to get out of her prison, and how her friends rallied around her at the end.

But, it also felt clunky. I think it went back and forth between the right amount of showing and telling, to lecturing me about what the characters were doing.  In the moments when there was a balance, I loved it, but then I would be jarred out of the story for a while, until I could get my groove again.

Maybe that’s a fault of my own, for not having read the first book, because I really did like the overall story (and while the story ended, I’m not sure it’s quite done). Even with its faults, it’s a good book.

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.)

by Vivian Vande Velde
ages: 11+
First sentence: “My mother isn’t normally the kind of parent who comes to school and has me yanked out of class because she needs to see me.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!

Grace Pizzelli is your average teenager. Nothing special (at least nothing like her older sister, Emily, who seems to be Perfect), but nothing terrible either. Then, one day, the CEO of Rasmussem, Inc., the creator of the world’s best virtual immersion games, comes to school to pull Grace out. It seems that Emily, who was working as an intern at Rasmussem, has plugged herself into a game and reprogrammed it so she can’t come out. She only has hours left to live before the being connected to the game overheats her brain (or something like that) and kills her.

It’s up to Grace to go into the game and find a way to get Emily out.

Once in, Grace discovers that the game she was expecting (something Gruesome and Horrible) Emily to choose is not the game she chose. No, this game is all sprites and pink and princes and sparkles. Nothing deadly here, right? Well…. the longer they are in the game, the more sinister it becomes. It turns out that not everything pink is fun and good.

This was a lot of fun to read. Aside from the having to save a sibling theme (there are a lot of those this year, and I’ve only read a sixth of those nominated!), the idea of having a fluffy video game turn against its players is a creative one. And, Velde’s pacing is tight. She kept me involved an interested in how the game is going (and whether or not Emily was going to make it out) through the whole book. And even though it got moralistic (the reason why Emily plugged herself into the game were not, shall we say, entirely honorable) in the middle and again at the end, it wasn’t horribly heavy handed.

No, the only drawback to the book was that I wanted more: the world to get More Evil, the sisters to have to Endure More Trials. It was all too… fluffy in the end.

That said, call it punk gamer fluffy. Which is a kind of fluffy that I don’t mind.

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.)

by Adam-Troy Castro
ages: 9+
First sentence: “The neighbors though Gustav Gloom was the unhappiest little boy in the world.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!

Gustav Gloom isn’t really the unhappiest little boy in the world. He just lives in a house full of ghosts and shadows, and not real people. It’s hard to be really happy when you don’t have a family or friends. But he’s not sad, either. The only real danger he has is staying out of the way of the People Taker and his Beast. It’s not a bad life.

Then a family moves in across the street, one that has two little girls — Pearlie and Fernie — who court danger. So, of course, Fernie wanders over to the Gloom Mansion (in the middle of the night) following her wandering cat.  Little does she know what she’s in for… (cue sinister music)

To be honest: this really wasn’t all that scary. Maybe it’s because I’m an adult (I need to have A read it, just to see if it is scary), but the Terrifying Parts weren’t all that Terrifying. That said, it was a pretty good adventure, a nice tale of friendship, with just a smidgen of ghosts and baddies.

But what really won me over with this one (yes, it’s the start of a series, but from what I can tell, they’re all individual adventures), was that it’s really tightly written, and excellently plotted. There was enough going on to keep me turning pages, and I enjoyed the journey.

And sometimes, that’s all a book needs.

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.)

by Katherine Applegate
ages: 9+
First sentence: “I am Ivan.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!

Months ago, I saw a review for this one over at Abby the Librarian, and I thought to myself: y’know, I ought to read that one.

But I’m not really into animal stories, and it kind of fell by the wayside. There is so much else to read, after all.

Then, we got the amazing luck to have it land on the Middle Grade Science Fiction/Fantasy list, for even though it’s not a fantasy in the traditional sense, it is a fantastical novel, something which probably could never happen, even though there’s a slight outside chance that it could.

I’m so happy we ended up with it.

Because, like Abby and others have said: it’s a wonderful novel.

Slim, written not in verse but rather in short sentences and chapters, it’s a story told by a gorilla in captivity. He’s not an especially happy gorilla, but he’s not an especially sad one either. Because his family was killed and he was sold when he was a baby, he doesn’t know anything other than captivity. He is friends with an old circus elephant and a mutt of a dog, and he has a sort-of relationship with Julia, the daughter of the nighttime janitor in the mall where Ivan lives.

He probably would have spent the rest of his life in his “domain”, until his owner buys a baby elephant, Ruby. Suddenly, Ivan has someone to protect. And he realizes that there could be more to his life, and Ruby, at least, deserves more.

It’s a simple novel, something that a third grader could get a grasp of. But it’s a powerful one: one that drew me into Ivan’s world, filled me with sympathy and love for these animals who just want to live a decent life. And yes, I did cry at the end.

It’s about time I read it. Beautiful.

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.) 

by Laura Amy Schlitz
ages: 10+
First sentence: “The witch burned.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!

Ever since I finished this evocative work by Newbery-award winning author Laura Amy Schlitz, I’ve been trying to describe it. I’ve come up with “a slightly magic Dickensian-inspired story” (to which it was suggested that those who liked Claire Vanderpool’s Moon Over Manifest would probably like this one).  I’ve also described it as an “evil puppetmaster who mistreats two orphan children gets his due”, which is fairly accurate. And then there’s the “wizard vs. witch battle” angle as well.

It is a Dickensian story: set in late-19th century London, it’s the tale of two orphan children who are taken in by a Fagin-esque puppetmaster. The master, Grisini, has terrified the boy, Parsefall, into helping him pick pockets. But the girl, Liza Rose, is clueless about Grisini’s true nature. Then a series of things happen: they perform a show at Clara’s house, a wealthy little girl who lives in a house of Mourning (her four siblings died of cholera), and then she goes missing. Then, Grisini and the children decide to stand up to their wicked master, and an injured Grisini goes missing as well.

So far, so good right?

Actually, the thing that held this novel together (for me at least) was Schlitz’s writing. It’s incredibly descriptive (a random sentence: “A whiff of strong perfume rose to her nostrils: sweet musk roses and another, more metallic smell, reminiscent of something or someone she disliked.”) and flowing. It starts with the witch, and you wonder where the book is going to go, especially after you meet the orphans, but somehow Schlitz makes it all work together seamlessly. There isn’t a wasted page, and even though the action slows way down in the middle, while the orphans are trying to figure things out, it was enough to hold my interest.

Which gets to my real problem with this book: it’s one of those ones that Adults think Kids should like. As I have yet to find a way to describe it in any way that my girls (at least) would even be remotely interested in. The cover kind of spooks them (“Why is there two puppets being controlled by a giant hand?”) and when I try to describe the complex and intricate story, they lose patience about halfway through.

It’s a good story, just not one that I think kids are going to flock to. (Please, tell me if I’m wrong, and how to describe it so that I can get kids interested in it, because I’m really at a loss!)

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.) 

Adam Gidwitz
ages: 11+
First sentence: “Once upon a time, fairy tales were horrible.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!
Others in the series: A Tale Dark and Grimm

Cousins Jack and Jill aren’t very special. Jack’s always trying to be one of the Big Boys in the village, following them around trying to be a part of the crowd, much to their annoyance. Jill’s the daughter of a Very Beautiful Queen (who was, initially the Very Beautiful Princess who threw a ball down a well which was rescued by a frog), and can never live up to her mother’s expectations, no matter how much she tries.

Then, two things happen: they make friends with a talking Frog (of the princess story) and they make a blood oath to find the Seeing Glass. Which means they have Adventures, of course. Like the first one, these adventures wander through retellings of traditional fairy tales (with some original ones thrown in, something I found out after reading the author’s note at the end). They kill some giants, outsmart some dwarves and meet a fire-breathing salamander with a very long German name, before heading home, exhausted, yet wiser for their adventures.

This one, much like the first in this series, has a lot going for it. A fabulous narrator, who interjects (perhaps not quite as often) with words of wisdom, advice, even though it’s a bit distracted this time around, actually forgetting to do its job a couple of times, to humorous effect. (“Sorry, sorry! Totally forgot! Last time! Promise!) In fact, my single favorite page is the one where the narrator gets all huffy that we, the readers, have imagined everything and leaves so that we can just figure out the rest of the story for ourselves. Too funny. 

It also is nice because this one works as a stand-alone. If you’ve read the first one, you are familiar with the world and the style of writing, but that’s the only things. This one is a completely separate storyline, with a completely separate set of characters having completely separate adventures. All of which I found to be refreshingly enjoyable.

My only quibble is that (and my memory may be faulty; it has been a while since I read the first one) this one didn’t seem to flow quite as smoothly as the first one. And that the Moral got a bit heavy handed at the end. Even so, it wasn’t enough for me to not thoroughly enjoy the humorous fairy tale genius that is Adam Gidwitz.

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.)  

by Mike Jung
ages: 9+
First sentence: “There are four Captain Stupendous fan clubs in Cooperplate City, but ours is the only one that doesn’t suck.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!

I would have had to read this one anyway, being nominated for the Cybils in my category and all, but Betsy gave me the little nudge I needed to bump it up to the top of my “need to read” pile by posting this last Sunday:

How can you NOT want to read a book after that??

Vincent and his friends George and Max are the three members of the “Captain Stupendous Fan Club.” Not the Official one. Or the girly one. Or the rich old lady one. What they lack in size (all three of the other ones being much bigger), they make up for in knowledge: they have made it their life’s work (all 13 years of it, anyway) to know everything about Captain Stupendous.

Who is Captain Stupendous, you ask?

He is the Superhero who protects Copperplate City from all manner of nefarious individuals: from the rogue bad guy to the master evil genius.

But, in fighting the Evil Professor Mayhem and his Indestructible Robot, something happens to Captain Stupendous. And suddenly, he is not What He Is Supposed To Be.  (I’m  not going to tell you what happens, even though it’s Really Cool. You’ll just have to read the book.) And it looks like Professor Mayhem is targeting Vincent’s family! Of course, it’s up to Vincent, George, and Max to help Captain Stupendous figure out how to beat Professor Mayhem and keep Copperplate City safe.

Yes, this is really over the top. WAY over the top. But, it worked for me. I liked the nod to the kind of superhero geekery that guys (and some girls) get into, knowing every little bit about the superhero they idolize. Jung just took it one step further and made the superhero a real, rather than made-up, person. Which, in my humble opinion, is way cool. And even though the cover screams GUY, there’s also a really strong female character in Polly, a girl that the three geeky guys end up befriending.

Additionally, Jung threw in all sorts of regular middle school tropes: there are bullies, and fears about grades, and parents that don’t understand their kids, and dealing with parents’ significant others, and even a love triangle (of sorts; but only with the adults). Sometimes, those parts feel a bit clunky — and to be fair, it took a little while for me to settle into the book; the beginning felt choppy — but, for the most part, I enjoyed the balance between “real” and “superhero”. It’s not all flying around kicking some serious robot butt or shooting at each other with lasers or jumping out of helicopters. (Though all that does happen.)

Which means this is really the perfect book for everyone. Right?

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.) 

by William Alexander
ages: 9+
First sentence: “Rownie woke when Graba knocked on the ceiling from the other side.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!

Rownie is the youngest “sibling” in Graba’s group of Grubs. Abandoned after his older brother, Rowan, disappeared, he was taken in by Graba, and sent on errands. Rownie’s town is not a happy place: the mayor has banned all theater, except for those put on by those already “changed”, the goblins. Additionally, Graba has a tendency to mind-control her Grubs into doing her will.

So, when Rownie happens upon a theater troop in the park, and they invite him to join them, he does. It turns out that this troop happened to know Rowan, and know that he’s an essential part in keeping back the coming flood.

I’m going to have to stop here; I’m not sure that summarizing this book is going to make much sense. It’s been nominated for a National Book Award this year, and so someone must have thought there was some merit in the story. Admittedly, while reading it, I didn’t dislike it. The structure is very theater-inspired, dividing the chapters into Acts and Scenes. But even more than that, it felt like watching a play. I can see why it was nominated, it’s gorgeously written and definitely the epitome of High Fantasy. But, I’m not sure I really liked it.

I’ve been trying, since I finished it, to figure out why. It wasn’t the story, or the characters, or the writing. In fact, I think this might make a good read-aloud. Perhaps it was that it all felt so… affected. Rather than being smooth and effortless, I felt like Alexander was trying too hard to Make A Fantasy and Tell A Story. And I never really connected to the story he was trying to tell.

But, honestly? It was probably just me.

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.) 

Heroes of Olympus, book 3
by Rick Riordan
ages: 11+
First sentence: “Until she met the exploding statue, Annabeth thought she was prepared for anything.”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!
Others in the series: The Lost Hero, The Son of Neptune

Dear Rick,

First: can I call you Rick? I mean, I’ve been a fan since I read the first Percy Jackson book (yeah, I know, I missed the Tres Navarre series until later, but that’s just because I’m not really a mystery sort of person) way back in 2005. I loved everything about it: the characters, the use of Greek mythology, the pacing: it was a great example of what middle grade fantasy can do.

But, Rick. Rick. You’ve lost the Touch.

I don’t know if it’s because you’ve been trying to write two series at once. Or if it’s because with all the demands of being a best-selling author, you’re churning out books too fast. Or if my expectations are just way too high. Whatever the reason: this one, as much as I love Percy, Annabeth and the rest of the clan, is just not a great book.

(As a brief aside, if you want to write a whole book about Leo Valdez, I will read it. Team Leo!)

It’s very much a middle-of-the-series book, as well. Sure, the group from Camp Half-Blood (Annabeth, Piper, Jason, and Leo from the first book) has to head to Camp Jupiter to pick up that group (Percy, Hazel, and Frank) and then end up in Rome in order to stop Gaea.  I get that. But, that’s all there really is to the plot. So, Rick, I ask you this: why did this book need to be 574 pages long?  Yeah, I get it: you want to weave in other myths and minor gods, but meeting Nemisis, Narcissus, Bacchus, Hercules, Chrysaor, plus the giants who are helping Gaea out is just way too many. I know: you’ve always thrown in a lot in your books, but for some reason this time around it just seemed cluttered. You threw out another god, and my reaction was, “Really? Another god?” rather than “Woot! Another god!”

Also: while I adore the cover (and know you have nothing to do with it), it gives the impression that you were going to address the rift between the two camps. That something Big was going to Happen, and that there was going to be a Grand Confrontation. There’s not, though it is implied at points. The whole point of this one, was to get the group from point A to point B, and I felt slighted by that.

Don’t fret, though: I am going to read The House of Hades, Rick. (I know you were worried.) I’m still invested in the series. But, you know: especially now that the Kane Chronicles are done, I hope for a better book. Something more like what you gave me back in the beginning.

Is that too much to ask?

Best,
Melissa (and girls. Their comments? “It’s not his best book.”)

(Just for the record: because this is a Cybils nominee, I’ve been asked to make sure y’all know this is my opinion only, and not that of the panel.)