by Martin Edwards
First sentence: “The snow lay deep and deadly,”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!
Release date: October 7, 2025
Review copy provided by the publisher.
Content: There is some mild swearing, a couple of f-bombs, and murder (of course). It will be in the Mystery section of the bookstore.

Welcome to Midwinter: a remote resort in northern England that is only open to a few people by invitation only. And this Christmas, it’s open to six people – all who are somehow connected to the publishing industry; all who have fallen on hard times – who have been tasked with solving a pretend murder. The winner gets a grand prize and a new lease on life. Except once they get there, people start dying. At first, it seems they are “accidental”, but as the bodies keep piling up, it becomes more and more obvious that the death that happened at Midwinter five years ago has had repercussions.

I picked this up because of the title, because it sounds like a game of Clue. And there is an interactive element to this; we are given the same information the players in the story are, and it’s possible (if you are not me) to figure out who committed the “pretend” murder. The actual murders in the story have a very Agatha Christie-like quality to them, as does the whole story. Our narrator for most of the book is Harry Crystal, a washed-up mystery writer, whose whole schtick was copying classic mysteries. I feel like, in some respects, that Edwards didn’t get me quite enough information as we went along (I’m not the closest of readers), because the solution came out of left field a little bit. Even so, I didn’t have super high expectations for this, only wanting a bit of fun, and it absolutely fit that bill.