Over Sea, Under Stone

by Susan Cooper
ages: 9+
First sentence: “Where is he?”
Support your local independent bookstore: buy it there!

I’ve been trying to remember when I first read these books. It wasn’t when I was a kid, even though I would have loved them had I come across them. I’m thinking it was about the time that I rediscovered kidlit, about 15 years ago. I don’t remember what I thought about this particular book — I do love the next one in the series, The Dark is Rising — but I did find I remembered elements of the plot.

Simon, Jane and Barney Drew are on vacation in Cornwall with their family and their Great-Uncle Merry. On their second day there, they’re exploring the old house that “Gumerry” rented for them and discover an old map. It turns out that the map is written in old English and Latin; it’s a guide of some sort leading to the Holy Grail. It’s up to the kids to figure it out and find the grail… before the “other” side does. There’s a bit of adventure, some kind of tense moments, and it’s truly a middle grade book: except for a bit at the end, it’s a straight-up mystery that’s solved by Simon, Jane and Barney working together.

All that said, it’s really kind of a silly little book. Aside from introducing us to Merry (Merriman Lyon, who shows up in the other books. He’s actually Merlin…) and the Drew kids (they do make a reappearance), I’m not quite sure what purpose this book serves to the whole of the series. (Maybe it’ll become clearer as I read more.) You could honestly not read this book and not be missing much of anything. The writing’s not even as evocative as I remember some of the other books in the series being.

It’s a good thing I don’t judge series by the first book.

9 thoughts on “Over Sea, Under Stone

  1. I tend to skip this one in my re-reading of the series, going straight to The Dark is Rising! I wonder how many readers have started this series, only to be put off…


  2. I guess I'm the opposite of everyone else. I like this book and Greenwitch better than the ones that focus on the anointed boy. I found all the destiny stuff with him too forced, too weird, and too lacking in tension. The “normal” kids were more interesting to me.

    They have the feel of mixing together the Hardy Boys (or the Bobbsey Twins?) with Swallows and Amazons.

    That's just me, though. I'm weird that way.

    This is a really strange series in how the alternating books are so similar to each other (or different? how to say? The odd books are more alike to each other than to the even books.)


  3. Wasn't this one published originally by a different publisher from the other four? For the longest time, it wasn't listed as part of the series, for that reason. For the longest time, I thought of it as the “lost” book in the series.


  4. I enjoyed this one as a good read-aloud to the kids, but it has such a different tone than the others. I like the more complex stories of the rest of the series.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s